STN vs. VoIP: How to Choose
Introduction
Choosing the right business phone system is no longer a simple technical decision. For many organisations, communications underpin customer service, internal collaboration, security, and long term operational efficiency. As traditional phone infrastructure ages and digital alternatives mature, businesses are increasingly faced with a clear choice between staying on the Public Switched Telephone Network or moving to Voice over Internet Protocol.
Both PSTN and VoIP can still support voice calls, but the way they operate, scale, and integrate with modern business systems is very different. In the UK, this decision has become even more pressing due to the national switch off of PSTN services and the rapid shift towards fully IP based communications.
PSTN vs. VoIP: How to Choose
Understanding PSTN
The Public Switched Telephone Network is the traditional copper based telephone system that has been in use for decades. It relies on physical phone lines connected to local exchanges, with voice transmitted as electrical signals.
PSTN systems are typically associated with desk phones connected to on site phone systems or directly to the exchange. Calls are billed per line and often per minute, particularly for long distance or international calls.
For many years, PSTN was the default option for businesses because it was reliable, widely available, and simple to understand. However, it was never designed for modern digital workflows, remote working, or integrated communications.
Understanding VoIP
Voice over Internet Protocol delivers phone calls over an internet connection rather than traditional phone lines. Voice is converted into digital data and transmitted over IP networks in the same way as email or video calls.
VoIP systems can be cloud hosted or installed on site, and they work across desk phones, laptops, tablets, and mobile devices. Most modern VoIP platforms include features such as voicemail to email, call analytics, call recording, mobile apps, and integration with CRM and collaboration tools.
VoIP has become the preferred option for many businesses because it is flexible, scalable, and designed to support modern ways of working.
Cost considerations
One of the most significant differences between PSTN and VoIP is cost structure.
PSTN systems involve line rental for each phone line, maintenance of physical infrastructure, and often higher call charges. Adding new users usually means installing additional lines, which can be slow and expensive.
VoIP typically uses a subscription model with predictable monthly costs per user. Calls, including national and international calls, are often included or significantly cheaper. Because VoIP uses existing internet connections, there is no need to install new phone lines when scaling up.
For growing businesses or those with fluctuating staff numbers, VoIP offers far greater cost control and transparency.
Scalability and flexibility
PSTN systems are inherently limited by physical infrastructure. Adding or removing lines requires engineering work, and changes can take weeks to implement. This makes PSTN poorly suited to businesses that are expanding, relocating, or adopting hybrid working models.
VoIP systems are designed for flexibility. New users can be added in minutes, numbers can be reassigned easily, and staff can make and receive calls from anywhere with an internet connection. This is particularly valuable for businesses with remote workers, multiple locations, or seasonal staffing requirements.
Reliability and call quality
PSTN has long been viewed as highly reliable because it operates independently of internet connectivity. In the past, this was a major advantage, particularly in areas with poor broadband.
However, broadband reliability in the UK has improved significantly. With a stable business grade internet connection and appropriate network configuration, VoIP call quality is consistently high. Many VoIP providers also offer failover options such as automatic call rerouting to mobiles during outages.
In practice, VoIP reliability now matches or exceeds PSTN in most business environments, especially when supported by proper IT infrastructure.
Features and functionality
PSTN systems offer basic calling features such as call transfer, voicemail, and hunt groups. More advanced functionality often requires additional hardware or expensive upgrades.
VoIP platforms include advanced features as standard. These commonly include call forwarding rules, call queues, auto attendants, voicemail transcription, call analytics, and integration with business software.
For organisations that rely on efficient call handling, customer insights, or multi channel communications, VoIP provides capabilities that PSTN simply cannot deliver.
Security and compliance
PSTN is physically secure but limited in terms of monitoring and control. Fraud detection and call reporting are often basic or unavailable.
VoIP security depends on proper configuration. When implemented correctly, VoIP systems use encryption, secure authentication, and network level protections. Reputable providers also support compliance with UK data protection requirements and industry regulations.
From a risk management perspective, VoIP offers greater visibility and control, provided it is managed by experienced IT professionals.
Future proofing and the UK PSTN switch off
One of the most important factors in choosing between PSTN and VoIP is future viability. In the UK, PSTN services are being withdrawn as part of the national move to all IP communications. This means traditional phone lines will no longer be supported, and businesses still using PSTN will be required to migrate.
VoIP is fully aligned with this transition. Moving sooner rather than later allows organisations to plan the change on their own terms, rather than rushing to meet deadlines.
Business type considerations
Small businesses often benefit from VoIP due to lower costs and ease of setup. Startups and growing companies gain flexibility without significant upfront investment.
Medium sized organisations typically value VoIP for scalability, remote working support, and integration with other systems.
Larger enterprises may use VoIP as part of a wider unified communications strategy, supporting voice, video, messaging, and collaboration across multiple locations.
PSTN may still suit very small operations with minimal requirements, but even in these cases, long term viability is limited.
Decision making framework
When choosing between PSTN and VoIP, businesses should consider current needs and future plans. Key questions include call volumes, number of users, remote working requirements, growth expectations, and IT support capabilities.
For most organisations, VoIP represents a strategic investment rather than a simple replacement for traditional phones.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Is PSTN still available in the UK
PSTN services are still available in some areas, but they are being phased out. Businesses should plan to move away from PSTN as part of long term communications planning.
Q2: Does VoIP require fast internet
VoIP requires a stable internet connection rather than extremely high speeds. A properly configured business broadband connection is usually sufficient for high quality calls.
Q3: Are VoIP calls secure
Yes, when implemented correctly. Modern VoIP systems use encryption and secure authentication to protect voice data.
Q4: Can VoIP work during internet outages
Many VoIP providers offer failover options such as forwarding calls to mobile devices or secondary connections during outages.
Q5: Is VoIP suitable for emergency calls
Yes, but emergency call configuration must be set up correctly to ensure accurate location information is provided.
Q6: How disruptive is the switch from PSTN to VoIP
With proper planning, migration can be smooth and minimally disruptive. Many businesses transition in stages to reduce risk.
Conclusion
Choosing between PSTN and VoIP is no longer just a technical preference. It is a strategic business decision shaped by cost efficiency, flexibility, reliability, and future readiness. While PSTN has served businesses well for decades, it is increasingly limited and approaching the end of its lifecycle.
VoIP offers a modern communications platform designed for today’s business environment. It supports remote work, scales easily, integrates with digital systems, and aligns with the UK’s move to all IP networks.
For most organisations, VoIP is the clear long term choice. The key is to plan the transition carefully, assess infrastructure readiness, and work with experienced professionals to ensure a secure and reliable implementation.
If you're seeking expert support in Cybersecurity Solutions, Cloud Computing, IT Infrastructure & Networking, Managed IT Support, Business Continuity & Data Backup, or VoIP & Unified Communications, visit our website, Dig-It Solutions, to discover how we can help your business thrive. Contact us online or call +44 20 8501 7676 to speak with our team today.
